Weathered vs. Rustic side-by-side comparison

So, what's your pick: Weathered or Rustic

We know why you're here... You can't decide between two of our seemingly identical colors: Rustic and Weathered. This is one of the most common questions we are asked, and we get it; the two colors do look incredibly similar. Let's explore the difference between the two and determine why they look similar in photos so you can pick the perfect color for your home.

 

When looking at the differences between Weathered and Rustic, or any of our colors of flooring, there are a couple of important things to keep in mind:

  • Each of our flooring colors will look different in different light settings, especially in photos. 
  • We try to only share unfiltered photos; however, when we are gathering images from a variety of cameras and phones, a specific color of flooring may look different from photo to photo and home to home.
  • The color scheme and design of your space will bring out the different tones in each of our flooring colors. 
  • Looking at your samples in natural lighting from the sun will be the best way to differentiate each color of flooring.   

Weathered vs. Rustic Comparison Table

 

Lighting

Natural white, daylight, warm, cool, LED, soft, and the list goes on — we understand not every home is going to have the same lighting, so here are side-by-side, comparison photos of Weathered and Rustic in two different light settings.

 

Daylight

In daylight, the darker variations in Weathered (left) will pop more, and you will see that Rustic (right) tends to look overall lighter in color.

Both of the colors look amazing in homes with bright lights, daylight and windows, but if you are wanting a flooring color that is overall lighter, we recommend you go with Rustic.

If your home has more soft, cool-toned lighting, both the colors will look similar to the photos below of Weathered and Rustic in daylight.

Weathered vs. Rustic side-by-side comparison in a natural light setting

 

Warm White

Obviously, the warm tones in Weathered and Rustic will be brought out in a warmer-toned light setting, and the variation is less apparent. The darker variations in Rustic (right) are bolder in this light setting.

In this light setting, you can see that the gray tones in Weathered (left) and the brown tones in Rustic (right). On the variation side of things, Rustic (right) looks more varied than Weathered (left).

If your home has more warm lighting throughout, and you are looking for a less brown-toned flooring, we recommend you go with Weathered.

Weathered vs. Rustic side-by-side comparison in a warm white light setting

 

Color Scheme

Depending on your personal style and the look of your space, Weathered and Rustic will look different in your home. Each color palette will bring out the different tones in each flooring color.

Decorating with browns, whites and pops of bright colors will bring out the warm tones in both Weathered and Rustic. On the flip side, homes that have a more modern look with black, white, and gold will bring out the gray tones in Weathered and Rustic.

(Below are photos of Weathered Stoneform® in a modern setting.)
Photos of Weathered Stoneform® by Becki Owens in a modern home
 
(Below are photos of Rustic Stoneform® in a modern setting.)
Rustic Stoneform® by Becki Owens in a modern home
 
(Below are photos of Weathered Stoneform® in a traditional setting.)
Weathered Stoneform® by Becki Owens in a traditional setting
 
(Below are photos of Rustic Stoneform® in a traditional setting.)
Rustic Stoneform® by Becki Owens in a traditional setting

 

Samples

We highly recommend getting a sample of both Weathered and Rustic, setting them in the area where you want to install the flooring, and keep them there for a few days. Every time you walk past, one will stand out more than the other.

*Pro tip: If a 12" sample is not enough for you to decide, you can order a couple more or a full plank.

Next, place the samples next to your furniture, decorations, and the different colors in your home to see the different tones and hues that are brought out in each sample of flooring. 

If you still can't decide, place each sample in the sunlight/natural daylight as this will show you each of the color's natural variations, hues, and differences.

 

Still confused?

Reach out to our in-house designer, Cailtin Weerts, from @studiofrancine.co. Here is the link to her calendar to schedule a free consultation with her.  

If you are still at a loss, don't worry. Give us a call, send us an email (customerservice@hewnfloor.com), or message on Instagram; we can talk you through the differences and help you decide on the perfect color for your home.

Back to blog